By Megan E. Smith (Updated 03/22/23)

The appeal of direct-vent traditional gas fireplaces can likely be found in their… well… traditional appearances. As much as we wish looks were the only thing that mattered when deciding what fireplace to buy, we know countless other factors come into play when searching for the perfect one. So let us do the hard work for you.  

Below are our “Top 5” direct-vent traditional gas fireplaces with all the shopping advice you need. Whether you’re in the market for a standard 35-inch or a 46-inch model that makes the traditional look a big deal, we’ve got you. Just kick back, relax, and let us help you find your next fireplace. 

Superior is known for dependable performance and diverse product lines, so it’s easy to see why they’re kicking off our guide with the DRT2000 Series. This series doesn’t come with any confusing bells or whistles. It’s straightforward. With one-size flame height, easy-to-access controls, several classic interior options, and a 17-inch depth to maximize floor space, this line suits a careful budgeter who’s searching for a fireplace with entry-level pricing and uncompromised quality. The DRT2000 Series has a starting price of $1,799.00 which is one of the best on the market!  

• High definition log set 

• 26,000-35,000 BTUs (depending on model size)
• Ceramic glass
• Protective screen
• Available in 35-inch, 40-inch, and 45-inch 
• Electronic ignition with seamless battery backup 

Although the timeless appearance of a traditional fireplace may start with a box and brick, it doesn’t stop there. Take one look at Napoleon’s Altitude ™ X Series and you’ll see why. This line is only available in two sizes, but, true to Napoleon Hearth’s reputation for customization, there are countless features and accessories that make it easy for a few splashes of the contemporary to land on an otherwise traditional fireplace. With a starting price of $3,299.00, this series checks off nearly all the boxes—it’s uniquely designed, offers technology like Napoleon’s heat management and eFIRE app, and is perfect if you’re in the market for a direct-vent fireplace that combines the traditional with contemporary. 

• Available in: 36-inch and 42-ich 

• Dynamic Heat Control 

• Dozens of accessories 

• Up to 38,000 BTUs (depending on model) 

• eFIRE mobile app

The DRT6300 series is stunning. Seriously, you won’t want to miss out on seeing the robust flames featured in this line. With its expansive ceramic glass and smooth-faced design, you won’t have to. Trust us. The DRT6300 is available in 40-inch or 45-inch models. If you’ve been searching for a direct-vent traditional see-through fireplace, this is also going to be the best fit for you because Superior offers a see-through model. The DRT63ST is 40 inches and is able to create the same flames as its one-sided counterparts. This line is one of the best in the direct-vent traditional game and has a starting price of $6,649.00. If you and your budget can throw caution to the wind, we promise you won’t be disappointed! 

• Available in: 40-inch and 45-inch 

• Offers 40-inch see-through model 

• 50,000-57,000 BTUs (depending on model size) 

• Clean-faced design

• Robust flames

Napoleon always makes your personal design a priority which is why their top-of-the-line Elevation™ X Series is our number one pick for a direct-vent traditional fireplace. The Elevation™ X’s impressive flames come to life when you hang your favorite artwork, TVs, or electronics directly above it. Even if you don’t want to place anything above the Elevation™ X, there are countless customization options that allow you to explore the contemporary and the traditional alike. With a starting price of $4,149.00, this fireplace is perfect for someone whose budget has legroom because you’ll want to take advantage of all its options.

• Hang TV, artwork, and electronics above the fireplace 

• Ten optional interiors 

• Three optional log sets 

• Four optional trim styles  

• Three optional fronts